Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers

I have spent the last two weeks reading Murder by the Book by Sally Munt, a book published in the 90’s exploring feminist crime fiction. As you can imagine, there are constant references to classics, so I saw myself stopping my study routine to read two wonderful crime fiction classics that had been on my to-be-read list for quite a long time: The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha Christie and Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers.

StrongPoison

From Goodreads:

Mystery novelist Harriet Vane knew all about poisons, and when her fiancé died in the manner prescribed in one of her books, a jury of her peers had a hangman’s noose in mind. But Lord Peter Wimsey was determined to find her innocent as determined as he was to make her his wife.

I have to say, Strong Polson (1930) made me use my e-reader again and this time I did not dread the reading process. Sayers’ mastery of plot and narrative is so excellent that I did not notice I was reading on my device, something that I am still struggling with. Also, Strong Poison is the fifth in the Lord Peter Wimsey series, but I had no problem getting acquainted with the characters in any way, which pretty much tells of Sayers’ ability to create great characters.

As a crime fiction reader, there is nothing that I like most than a meta narrative, and Sayers produces the reader with the perfect story here: a female crime fiction writer that is accused of killing her partner with whom she was illicitly living. I loved reading about a woman crime fiction writer in the 1930’s and all the connotations that it implied. Harriet Vane’s literature is regarded as unimportant and unsuccessful even though she makes a living as a writer and her works were much more well-known that those of her partner, who by the way, wrote better literature, or so the rest of the characters say. It was also very interesting to read about the prejudices that such a woman had to face, one of them being that she was angry at her partner for not wanting to marry her, when it was actually the other way round. Murder by the Book describes Harriet Vane as the first example of a sexually active and independent woman in crime fiction and I cannot but agree. I have to admit I was shocked at how Harriet very much set the tone for the relationship and was the main bread-winner in the family.

As for Lord Peter Wimsey and his family, I fell in love immediately with them. I even pictured his mother as Maggie Smith in her role in Downton Abbey as the dowager. They seemed quite an unusual family for the 1930’s, so I really want to learn more about them. But, Wimsey as a detective was one of a kind. He is an aristocrat, but he is funny and quirky and I loved how direct he was when he confessed Harriet he wanted to marry her. I could not but think of these ladies portrayed in TV shows as crazy for wanting to marry serial killers! At first I was shocked that he would bring up the marriage issue so quickly, but Sayers makes Harriet an independent woman when she lets her ponder her answer. Also, the conversation he and Harriet had about their previous sexual encounters was very sincere and I think Sayers did a great job at making them equals and setting the tone for – I hope – a future relationship based on equality and respect.

Sayers’ books are often accused of being racist and classist. I could see the classist prejudices in the same way I could see them in Christie’s: the servants appear as rough and uncultured. There is also a lack of racial diversity, but taking into account Lord Peter’s social status, this is no surprise. So, as you can see I am actually more willing to let certain things pass in Sayers’ stories that I am not in Christie’s. This only shows how much I loved Strong Poison and I really plan on reading the following installments.

So, I would recommend this crime fiction classic to everyone. As a product of the crime fiction Golden Age, there are not shocking scenes, too many corpses or forensic details. Strong Poison is what I would call a cozy crime novel, and a very good one.

Want another opinion? Keishon from ‘Yet Another Crime Fiction Blog’ also loved Strong Poison. Click here to read her review.

It also made it to Marina Sofia’s post on the best Sayers works at Crime Fiction Lover. Click here to read the post.

22 thoughts on “Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers

  1. Great review! I love Strong Poison, as I love all the Wimsey mysteries – you really captured it. I prefer Sayers to Christie too, I just find her more interesting & subtle. I wish you many more cozy hours with Lord Peter 🙂

    1. Oh, how cool you too prefer Sayers! I think she is a better writer – to put it plainly – and Lord Peter is a much more interesting and funny character than Poirot. Having said that, I still have to read the Mrs. Marple series.

      I think you’ll see more of Lord Peter around here 😉

    1. I haven’t, Elizabeth, but I am doing some research on her right now, thank you. And yes, I can’t wait to read what the future brings to Harriet and Peter 🙂

  2. Yes, if you read more Sayers the more you will know about their relationship and see how it develops. I think the next one where she appears is Have his carcase which I really really like.

    1. That’s great, Rikki. I need to google the titles and try not to spoil anything. I think these novels will come very handy when I’m stressed or feeling down. Am I right? 🙂

    1. Oh, I’m sorry I don’t like Christie and did such a comparison, but I think you’ll love this series as well. Please let me know when you read them, I really want to know what a Christie fans thinks of Sayers.

  3. Oh yes I have read this one, when I read the title I couldn’t remember. I loved it. I also like the fact that we don’t get gruesome scenes in these Golden age crime novels.

  4. Thanks for the link! I’m so glad you enjoyed Strong Poison. As you know, I loved it. I’d heard the same criticisms about Sayers as well and was willing to bypass them, too. Her work has stood the test of time well. You must read Georgette Heyer when you get the chance. My favorite scene in Strong Poison has to be the seance scenes. The beginning wasn’t bad either with the long drawn out courtroom scenes. There are I think four books that feature Ms. Harriet Vane and Lord Peter together.

    1. If I am sincere, Keishon, I don’t feel like I bypassed them, but more like I didn’t see them as clearly as I saw them in Christie.

      And now that you say it, I wonder why Harriet Vane appears on other 4 books only… I hope she doesn’t die! (And I really don’t want to know, so please no one who read this tells me 😀 )

      And I know, Heyer is another writer I have to read. I need to, I have to. I cannot write my PhD without reading her!

      1. I haven’t read the other three….so her fate is unknown to me, too. I meant to say the same thing about the criticisms of Sayers. I should have said: enjoyed despite of…interesting what you will see with Heyer because she had similar accustations tossed at her as well.

  5. Good review, Elena. I bought a Sayers’ novel for the first time a couple of weeks ago not really knowing much about her/the book. Looking forward to reading it now I’ve seen your thoughts.

    1. I can’t wait to hear what you think about Sayers (and whether you’ll bypass the little gender attrocities and the big classist ones).

  6. Your comments make me really want to read Sayers, soon! Elena, you have to stop adding to me TBR list, I don’t have enough time. 😉 Actually, I’m just happy to hear that you enjoyed reading this. (And really, Sayers was already on my list, you’ve just pushed her up it a bit.)

Have something to say?